Lesson plans are built for one audience: the whole class. Here’s how to plan instead for the 30 people actually in it.
Reality TV fans can tell within two episodes which Love Island contestants the producers care about the most. Those genetically-blessed islanders get confessionals and dramatic slow-motion walks. Everyone else gets four seconds by the fire pit and a sad suitcase shot on the way out of the villa.
Fans call it “the edit,” and every classroom has one too.
The issue with most lesson plan templates is that it leaves room for exactly one audience, and it’s the entire class as if it were a monolithic entity. We all know the roster is a lot more crowded than that.
Thirty kids walk in with their own pace and a whole life outside of school, usually with a phone buzzing in a hoodie pocket. Teachers reach more of those kids when they treat the room like an ensemble cast. That means keeping tabs on each student’s storyline and building the lesson around the actual humans in the chairs.
Jenna Falconer has spent 16 years learning to follow every storyline in the room. She taught in person in Illinois, Texas and Minnesota for over a decade before moving to virtual teaching. Currently, she’s our English Language Arts Teacher of Record Lead at Subject. (If you’re wondering, a teacher of record is the licensed teacher responsible for a student’s grades in a course. In other words, the grades stop at their desk.)
Jenna’s team holds active teaching licenses in 25 to 30 states, and some of them carry upwards of 500 students each. That’s a lot of names to learn, and her team learns their stories too.
How the heck do they do it? Well, with four small habits that help a teacher truly see every one — from the kid who’s stalling in class to the kid carrying something heavy that no child ever should. She shares how you can develop each habit and fit them inside a regular school day, without even needing a new binder to get you started.
Key takeaways:
- Teachers reach more students when they track each kid’s pace and life outside school and plan lessons around the whole class roster.
- A student who finishes a unit unusually fast may have rushed, so teachers should check understanding before moving that student ahead.
- Teen life changes fast. The share of U.S. teens online almost constantly rose from 24% in 2014-15 to 46% in 2023, per Pew Research.
Every backpack has a backstory
Jenna’s read on the job can be explained in a single soundbyte: “We’re more than just content experts.”
Sure, on paper, teaching comes down to knowing your content, but it also requires keeping the room running. Jenna did both jobs at once for years, and she hasn’t forgotten how it felt.
“I was solely responsible for the content, solely responsible for the behavior management,” she explains, later confessing that “ it never felt like me, as one person, was enough to fulfill all of these things.”
Anyone who has taught fifth period on a Friday knows that feeling in their bones. The bell schedule expects one adult to teach a lesson to 30 personalities and also notice the kid having a rough week. All of that has to happen in roughly the time it takes to microwave a Hot Pocket and walk it back to the copy room, where the copier is jammed again. (It’s always jammed. At this point the copier has tenure.)
The cast keeps changing on top of all that.
“Kids I had 10 years ago are not the same kids that I would have in a classroom now. They’re different. They have access to different things.”
The hard data agrees with her. In Pew’s 2014-15 surveys, about a quarter of teens said they were online almost constantly. By 2023, that share had climbed to 46%. That’s a lot more kids with one foot in the group chat during third period.
When the outside world moves that fast, shutting the classroom door on it is a pretty reasonable reflex. Phones go in pouches and class gets 50 minutes of peace. Plenty of thoughtful teachers and whole districts have drawn that line, and it’s hard to blame them.
The catch is that a kid’s outside life walks in anyway, usually zipped inside a backpack. Jenna’s teachers hear about it during their check-ins. “Oftentimes, we’ll deal with kids who will bring up to one of our teachers of record that they’re homeless or there’s just a catastrophe that happens,” she says. When that happens, Jenna passes the information to the school so it can line up support. Sometimes the school already knows. “Other times, they do not.”
In New York City alone, more than 154,000 public school students experienced homelessness in 2024-25, close to 1 in 7. Those students had seats in somebody’s classroom.
Run the room like a reality show
When we asked Jenna which TV show closely relates to teaching, she skipped all the shows entirely and went straight for the camera.
“Reality shows all have people with different personalities and different life experiences going on,” she says.
“On those shows, the camera is just trying to keep track of everything and build that story together. I feel like as teachers, that’s what we’re doing in the classroom.”
Strangely enough, Love Island runs on the same idea. The producers film the villa around the clock, then sit in a dark room deciding whose story the audience gets to follow. A teacher’s version of that job, despite getting neither a dark room or the craft service, works best when every kid makes the final cut—when every kid gets an edit. Jenna’s team pulls it off every week with hundreds of students, and it comes down to four habits.
How to follow 30 student storylines at once
The Confessional
Twice a week, Jenna’s teachers of record send each student a short note that amounts to a hello and a check on how they’re doing. Results vary. “Sometimes our kids respond, sometimes they don’t,” Jenna says. Other kids treat it like a group chat with a licensed educator. “Some students really like it. There’s a lot of back and forth.”
Both outcomes count as information. The kid who suddenly goes silent is telling you something, and so is the kid who replies with a full paragraph about the reading plus a meme.
In a physical classroom, the confessional can be a “how’s it going” at the door or a line at the bottom of an exit ticket. Teachers already do a version of this all day without giving it a name. Jenna describes teachers as “the one in the classroom, facing the students, reading the room all day long.” The habit is noticing when a kid’s answer changes, then circling back.
The Pacing Edit
Every kid in the cast moves at a different speed, and Jenna’s team keeps an eye on both ends of the range. Some students fall behind, and the message to them is refreshingly direct: “You’re really behind. Here are ways that we can support you.” It’s honest, and it shows up with a plan attached.
Then there’s the other end of the bell curve. A kid who wraps up a two-week unit by Tuesday might be a genius. That kid might also be speedrunning it like a Mario Kart time trial, hitting every shortcut and skipping the scenery. Jenna’s team checks before anybody throws a parade. Some students “zoomed through some things way too fast, and so we’ll pump the brakes for them and be like, hold on, we need to get you some support.”
The class average is an excellent hiding spot for both of those kids. Look at who’s racing and who’s stalled, and suddenly they’re back in frame.
The Producer’s Call
Some storylines are bigger than one classroom. When a student shares something like losing their home, Jenna’s job is to get that story to the people with resources. “I provide the school with that information so they can align their resources and support that kid,” she says.
This is the habit that takes weight off a teacher’s shoulders. Following every kid’s story leaves plenty of room for backup on the hard chapters. Counselors and social workers are trained for the red-alert episodes. The teacher’s part is making sure they hear about it, then getting back to the lesson.
The Reunion Special
At the end of a unit, take a quick look back at the cast and notice who barely showed up in the footage. That’s the whole exercise. It takes less time than the attendance software takes to load, and you walk away with a short list of names to watch a little closer next time.
Sometimes the fix lives in the material itself. When Jenna helped build Subject’s courses for English learners, her team wrote original stories so students would see themselves in the reading.
The goal was to “make them feel seen and heard.” Rewriting the curriculum every month is off the table for anyone who also enjoys sleeping. A reading choice or a writing prompt can still hand a few more kids a speaking role.
Keeping up when the cast changes every season
Early in Jenna’s career, Snapchat took over her students’ phones, so she did the slightly braver thing and figured out how it worked.
“I wanted to know what those things were and how kids were using them,” she says. “And so if they brought it up or I saw something, I would know if it was appropriate or not. And if I can use it as a teaching moment or not.”
The same habit works on whatever comes next. In 2026, that might mean investigating why seventh graders still yell “6-7” every time a page number has a six in it. (There’s probably a math lesson in there, but definitely some ibuprofen.)
Jenna gives AI the same treatment. “I think honestly, it’s not going anywhere,” she says.
She frames keeping up as growth that runs both ways. “The whole point of being a teacher is to progress and develop and change just the same way that your students do,” she says. At Subject, we apply the same thinking to its courses, with teams constantly “going back in, making sure that stuff is where we need it to be for kids in 2026, and then again in 2027.”
The final cut has room for everyone
Of course, no one would expect teachers to run a 24/7 reality show with a full roster of cast members. When getting a new coffee maker in the faculty lounge is out of the picture, it’s safe to assume the production budget alone would make a school board faint.
Thankfully, the teacher edit works on a much smaller scale, like a check-in at the door or a quick call to the counselor when a storyline gets heavy.
Jenna sums up the whole cast in one perfect final line.
“We’re all here right now trying to get a job done.”
Every kid in the room is part of that job, and every one of them deserves a storyline worth following. Now, cue the slow-motion walk, fade to black, and roll the credits.
FAQs
How can teachers keep track of every student in a large class?
Teachers can keep track of every student with short, regular check-ins. Subject’s teachers of record message students twice a week to ask how they’re doing. A student who stops replying sends a signal, and a quick hello at the classroom door works the same way.
What should a teacher do when a student is falling behind?
A teacher should name the problem directly and offer support in the same message. Subject’s teachers of record tell students they’re behind and list ways to get help. Pairing the news with a plan gives the student a clear next step.
Should teachers ban new apps and trends students bring to class?
Teachers can learn how a new app or trend works before deciding whether to ban it. ELA lead Jenna Falconer studied Snapchat early in her career. She wanted to judge whether it was appropriate and whether it could become a teaching moment. She applies the same test to AI today.
What should a teacher do if a student says they are homeless?
A teacher who learns a student is homeless should share that information with the school’s counselors or administrators. School support staff can then line up resources for the student. Sometimes the school already knows about a student’s situation, and other times the teacher’s report is how the school finds out.